The integration of non-health measures like ASCOT and ICECAP into National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidelines has not been widely adopted, raising questions about their potential impact on health and social care decisions in the UK. Despite the established role of quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) for evaluating health interventions, the consideration of broader social care outcomes remains limited. The review of NICE guidelines, alongside insights from industry experts, sheds light on the underutilization of these measures and explores upcoming developments that may influence future guidelines.
Diving into ASCOT and ICECAP Usage
The study analyzed how ASCOT and ICECAP have been utilized within NICE’s social care and public health guidelines up to August 2025. These measures appeared sparingly, with ASCOT used in only 4% and ICECAP in just 1% of the examined guidelines. Despite their presence, they did not play a crucial role in decision-making processes within the committees.
Challenges and Opportunities Identified
Expert interviews revealed underlying reasons for the limited usage of these measurements. The discussion revolved around three primary subthemes: conceptual misunderstandings, overarching systematic issues, and challenges in implementation. Furthermore, experts highlighted ongoing developments and potential future opportunities for the integration of these measures. The insights brought to light the need for a nuanced understanding of these outcomes and their implications for decision-making.
-The review shows a minimal adoption of ASCOT and ICECAP in NICE guidelines.
-Expert opinions categorize reasons into conceptual, system-wide, and implementation challenges.
-Ongoing advancements might enhance the utilization of these measures in the future.
Understanding the obstacles hindering the adoption of non-health outcomes is vital for enhancing care quality assessments. While the barriers currently restrict their broader application within NICE guidelines, experts stress that they are not insurmountable. Strategies to overcome these challenges include raising awareness, enhancing conceptual clarity, and addressing systematic issues. To make these measures a mainstay in assessing social care impacts, stakeholders must collaborate on continued research and dialogue. This will ensure that diverse outcomes are duly considered, ultimately enriching the spectrum of evaluative tools used by health and social care entities.
This article has been prepared with the assistance of AI and reviewed by an editor. For more details, please refer to our Terms and Conditions. We do not accept any responsibility or liability for the accuracy, content, images, videos, licenses, completeness, legality, or reliability of the information contained in this article. If you have any complaints or copyright issues related to this article, kindly contact the author.
